Steve Thomas is a Boston-based jazz singer but--surprise--his focus is almost all on original pieces. He writes his whimsical, sometimes surreal literate story songs for his band the Co-Conspirators--vibist Rich Greenblatt, bassist John Funkhouser, and drummer Gary Fieldman. The tunes mix trad rhythms from New Orleans and Brazil with the harmonies and angular phrasing of jazz.
- The Boston Phoenix, Feb. 2, 2007
SPIRITS PASSING THOUGH
Steve Thomas and the Co-Conspirators
Steve Thomas (vocals, songs, arrangements), John Funkhouser (bass), Rich Greenblatt (vibes), Gary Fieldman (drums)
DO we need more time and space? I'm not sure on either account...but I like SPIRITS PASSING THROUGH. ("Liking" or not is close to the least interesting thing you can say about music, when it's necessary to say anything at all, but there it is.) This is credible work which sounds like faint praise but it's not meant to be; I mean that this CD doesn't sound like R&D for the album you're going to make someday. Your first album, with Ben Schwendener, felt more R&D-ish but this stands up as a cohesive work -- almost a "concept album" (remember those?).
The timbre of the band works well. It's enough instrumentation to flesh out the harmony without cluttering up the voice and the lyrics. Maybe this album should be filed near Dolphy's OUT TO LUNCH, since it's that same approach with vibes taking the place of the piano and/or guitar. Speaking of guitar, do you remember DUSTER, a band (this was around the late 60s) with Gary Burton, Steve Swallow, Larry Coryell and Roy Haynes? During the vibes solos on "So Cold" and "Time/Space" I smiled to hear Duster but with Jack DeJohnnette on drums. When the three piece bass/drums/vibes vibing kicks in throughout the disk, it's like some kind of self-activating machine that roars into motion without warning. But (thankfully) this machine, animated by the spirits passing through, has a soul. The machine far exceeds factory specs on "By the Factory Wall" where Rich seems to find a groove he can really sink his teeth into. The vibes solos throughout the album are truly ensemble bits. There's no foreground or background -- they're integrated statements by all three musicians.
The album starts strongly with "Didier et Chocolat." It's a warm, inviting beginning and I think this is one of the most together pieces on the disk. "So Cold" is another one of my favorites. Somewhere in the first part of the album there's a moaning vocal solo that I'm not sure works, but it doesn't detract from the tune. In the middle of the proceedings I recall how an instrumental passage depicts time suspended over a couple of decades of Chuck Fisher's life. That music travels through some kind of temporal passageway leading to the re-entry of the vocal which makes it explicit: "Time passes by..." I find myself drawn deeper into the story, as the lyrics satisfy my curiosity. "Beads" covers similar territory; it's ambitious since the territory it's trying to cover is bigger than Louisiana and Texas put together. John's arco, unaccompanied bass solo communicates something about memory and reflection in the midst of the re-telling.
The band finds itself on its most familiar terrain on the clever "Reframed." The bass in its walking intro and solo suggests the era of the Ray Browns, Oscar Pettifords up to the George Duviviers, but without resorting to cliche. You might expect Percy Heath to be the bass reference here, but John is more bluesy and gritty. The vocal solo on this tune is a stand out. There's no stereotypes in this scat, cats! This tune is very different in mood than the others, and by the time you get to this point in the album it's a welcome off-set. The last two tunes are my favorites. Re: "By the Factory Wall" -- I'm a hopeless sucker for a funky back-beat, and, as mentioned above, the instrumental part cooks. Steely Dan makes a brief appearance in this tune somewhere. "Are We There?" is the finest performance on the album...from a performance standpoint. After the tighter, more constructed things, my ear was happy to get something that breathed just a bit more and allowed you to stretch out a little. There's an obvious rapport between you and Funkhouser, and the duo tunes you did when I saw you guys 'live' were a highlight. I'm looking forward to more from the Thomas/Funkhouser duo, as a part of the "S.T. and the Co-Cons." quartet. "Are We There?" is the performance I see myself returning to the most from this album. In short, I think you chose the best tunes for the openers and the closers -- the album begins and ends on strong notes.
Gary is such a good player. I love hearing what he's going to play next, even from moment to moment. I hear Elvin in there; it's as driving as that but not as relentless and there's more of a concern for variety and text. A single tune can become an encyclopedia of groove. The drums have a compositional role throughout the album. Some tunes are held together by the drums, and my ear goes first to them, and then hears the other musicians (and even the compositions themselves) in light of the what the drums are doing. I'm admitting to being jealous that you get to play with Gary as much as you might.
Lyrically -- but not only lyrically...the whole enterprise -- brings to mind Joni Mitchell. In this lyric-world things are what they are. Events stand and the song is a reflection, but one which is as unmediated as any reflection or memory can be. There's no mythologizing. The portraiture and biographic realism in the lyrics are Joni-ish as are the allusions to various genres, popular and otherwise, in the service of a modern art song...but one that grooves and improvises.
My one global criticism is on the composition rather than the execution. There's a same-y-ness about the vocal melodies. It's in the way these melodies tend to float over the ground beat. I might want to hear some more different rhythmic values in the notes, maybe some faster triplets or a brief string of eight notes. When I hear the vamp at the beginning of a tune, I can predict how the vocal melody is going to begin, and, although I have a reasonable tolerance for predictability, my sense is that that's not what you're going for. (When I said something like this before you dismissed me as a "Rock guy" (although I doubt I'm really that much more of a 'rock guy' than John or Gary) but my ears are telling me something that you might consider.) There's a compositional contrast between your instrumental and vocal melodies that might inform this a bit. Monk's around when you're writing the vamps and little lines you sprinkle around the tunes; maybe your vocal melody could be in that spirit a bit more (?).
Leaving aside that one beef, I have this album on my CD changer next to Monk solo piano from Paris. I went from one to the other last night with a seamless transition. I think a later Steve Lacy album might take its place in the changer after that. Good company, all.
David Vermette - December 11, 2006